As you amble north from the Inn, back toward the Village Green, explore Old Worthington's downtown shopping district. Shops like Damsels in This Dress are tucked away in nooks and crannies, and they are definitely worth the hunt.
There's also a truly cool hardware store -- the old-fashioned kind, with people who know how to help you with your projects. And if you're looking to relax over a casual dinner, one of my favorites is the fish-and-chips and locally-brewed ale at the Old Bag of Nails Pub.